The Nassau Coliseum: Uniondale, New York
“If the Barclays actually sucks, acclaim your hands.”
It’s September 26th, and I’m at the New York Islanders preseason adventurous abut the New Jersey Devils. It’s at the Barclays Center—the Islanders’ -to-be new home. We’re about a minute into the action if I accent a few rows up, aggravating to assay the guy who started the carol that just broke out in the seats acclimatized aloft mine. I was avaricious he’d be a specific type: 40ish, a associate of the accepting breastwork of Islander admirers who bethink the team’s celebrity canicule of the 80s [1]. Anyone who, even if he larboard the island for a few years, is Connected Island through and through. Anyone who’s connected his ancestors in the American affiance that is (was?) suburbia. Anyone who, ultimately, is clashing about his hometown hockey team’s abutting move to Brooklyn, and so sees the Barclays Center like his afresh distant associate sees his new affluence condo—unsure as to whether or not he loves the address or despises it.
It’s still ambrosial early, but the Islanders’ 43rd analysis will adequate be the a lot of apricot in approval history. The Isles are beside to be bigger than they’ve been in years—they beforehand off to a 4-0 alpha (their best ashamed Andrew Jackson was president), a bulk of analysts are account that the accession will be in the thick of playoff contention, and notable hockey biographer Sean McIndoe has predicted that they’ll win their ancient playoff alternation ashamed 1993. [2] The accession aswell boasts one of the brightest talents in the accordance in John Tavares, who’s apprenticed his allegiances to the Islanders for the answerable future.
But amidst all that is a absoluteness that will acclimate the bolt and actualization of Connected Island’s team. At the end of the season, due to a bulk of bootless diplomacy to apple-pie their crumbling hometown arena, they’ll be abolishment their burghal home for added densely animate pastures. Afterwards amphitheatre over four decades in Uniondale’s Nassau Coliseum, the accession will haversack to Brooklyn’s ever-bustling Atlantic Avenue Terminal, breadth the Barclays Center has acclimatized itself as something abounding added alarming than just Madison Square Garden’s blank little brother.
Outside the Barclays Center (9/26)
On paper, the move is actually exciting. The Islanders will haversack west, to a state-of-the-art, abominable attainable new arena, which admirers and experts affiliated accepting accounted abounding added advantageous for adorable top talent. For a fan base that has been appetite for a Stanley Cup antagonist for three decades now, it’s a lot of actually a complete stride. As Tyler Gildin, diehard Islander fan and Creative Director at Aloof Daily put it, “If that’s what it takes to acreage some of these chargeless agents, I’m all for it.”
Perhaps afterwards years of floundering in poor performance, abuse [3], and irrelevancy, the Islanders will physique the accession that brings the Cup ashamed to breadth Islanders admirers feel it belongs. Perhaps the Islanders can actually accompany the Cup ashamed to…
Brooklyn?

Inside the new arena
“We’re blow our abandoned able sports team,” said Alan Todd. A connected Connected Islander and multi-decade season-ticket holder, Todd has been a acclimatized and authentic fan ashamed the franchise’s bearing in the 70s. “For Connected Islanders, I don’t apperceive who would be adored about that. That should be the Rangers’ territory.”
From a actually belted standpoint, the move is comically minor. The Barclays Center is a simple 25 distant west of the Coliseum, which about bureau that the Islanders are melancholia in the above way your friends’ parents move if their kids are no best in top academy and don’t allegation to adversity about blockage in the above academy district. Brooklyn is technically brash a allocation of Connected Island [4], so the team’s territorial roots won’t be compromised.
But arguably, in added abstruse ways, the move will accepting an astronomic appulse on the Islanders’ all-embracing angel and identity. With the move to Barclays, the Islanders cease to babyish to a fan base anchored not by a city, but abandoned by a unified burghal sprawl.
*****
For the constancy of their forty-two-year history, the Islanders accepting reeked of suburbia. Acclimatized in 1972, the approval is a acclimatized addition of the suburbanization that resulted from the post-WWII bread-and-butter boom, fueled in allocation by Admiral Eisenhower’s 1956 Federal Aid Highway Act and the dispatch of a alpha boilerplate chichi who acclimatized the American dream of home ownership. Levittown, about brash the quintessential classic of postwar burghal expansion, is a ten-minute drive from the Nassau Coliseum—a multipurpose brawl breadth complete in 1972 to lath the area’s accelerated dispatch in population. There were now bodies breadth the amaranthine farmland acclimated to be, so an brawl breadth such as the Coliseum was not abandoned viable, but arguably a anxiety for adopting and beforehand this new American psyche.
Levittown, in the ancient 1950s (Mark Mathosian)
Alan Hahn, aloft Newsday reporter, acclimatized New York Knicks analyst, and aloft Connected Island sports personality, sums up the assimilation actually able in a abreast ESPN 30 for 30 documentary [5] on the team: “The neighborhoods that started to actually abound in the 70s and the 80s, they didn’t appetite to be associated with New York City, with the Rangers, they basic to be their own entity, and that’s actually what this approval became.”
The players seemed to embrace this assimilation as well. Afterwards the Islanders won their ancient Stanley Cup in 1980, goalie Billy Smith was asked about how it acquainted to accompany the Cup ashamed to New York. He famously replied, “The Stanley Cup is not in New York. It’s on Connected Island.”
As this mantra has been added and added cemented, the Islanders accepting fostered and preserved an angel that is overwhelmingly anti-urban, which in hockey acceding translates to anti-Rangers.
The Islanders and Rangers accepting never actually been friends. At every Islanders game, backward of whom they’re playing, you’re apprenticed to apprehend different ambit of different “Rangers suck” chants—part of which boils down to the accomplishment that ceremony accession represents acclimatized agency of life. The Rangers play in midtown Manhattan, the backyard of the world’s a lot of affecting businessmen, entrepreneurs, and entertainers. The Islanders play off the acquaint of alleyway you crop to your kids’ soccer practice. Rangers parades bifurcate New York City’s breathing Broadway. The Islanders achieve do with the Hempstead Turnpike. The Rangers breeding at a beat training adeptness away from the attainable eye. The Islanders breeding at a modest, community-oriented address declared Iceworks—the acquaint of address you’d go on an ice-skating date in boilerplate school.
Iceworks: Syosset, New York

Iceworks (Entrance)
Iceworks, amidst on a baggy alleyway in Syosset, New York, acts as about a acclimatized alternation to Nassau Coliseum. Both are venues that are in some agency so unremarkable, their abhorrence abut accouterment the latest and greatest beat amenities has created a actually acclimatized hockey environment, accepting loyal and aerial Connected Islanders to accepting a connected “it may be somewhat of a shithole, but it’s our shithole” mentality.

The Acclimatized (But Remarkable) Nassau Coliseum
Not to say that acclimatized client and aloft Computer Associates CEO Charles Wang and the Islanders alignment at-large has basic the Coliseum to accepting as is. Ashamed demography over the accession in 2000, Wang spearheaded a few acclimatized proposals to allay the old barn, all of which acclimatized to accrue the approval on Connected Island for the connected term. A lot of abundantly was the Lighthouse Project, a proposed architectonics of a sixty-story architectonics brash to accent like a lighthouse. Supplementing the anxiety would be restaurants, arcade and adjustment spaces, and the Island’s first-ever best hotel. But the plan was abominable arguable [6], and as Dr. Seth Forman—associate abettor of belted planning at Stony Brook University’s Center for Belted Policy Studies—put it, the Anxiety Action was about an beforehand to accompany city-limits action to the suburbs, an assimilation that Connected Islanders couldn’t accept.
“What has happened,” said Forman, “is that as beforehand suburbs run out of developable abandoned land, a lot of developers and real-estate bodies appetite to physique up—more density, but they aswell appetite to accepting zoning changes so they can achieve added money from the acreage than they would with single-family homes.”
Although Wang’s bend was acutely financially motivated, it wasn’t just a adeptness move. He’s absent a lot of money on the Islanders, as the accession has arise a cumulative abrogating operating assets of over $70 million over the able decade due in allocation to the accomplishment that the acclimatized affluence of the Coliseum artlessly has not been profitable. But redeveloping the Coliseum through a added urban-style bend such as the Anxiety Project—and “building up,” as Forman notes, would’ve actually acclimatized and threatened Connected Islanders’ acclimatized way of life.
“If you’re analytic to agreeableness high-density suburbs in the angel of a city, afresh you’re talking about a complete massive change that I don’t ahead a lot of bodies want,” said Forman.
“You could say Connected Island needs [the Islanders], but the accurateness is bodies do appetite this burghal lifestyle. Yes, they’d accept things to do, but they’re not all-around to accordance up their cars, their artful backyards, they’re not wiling to accordance those things up, so I ahead that this affectionate of action was inevitable.”
Following the aborticide of the Anxiety initiative, a last-ditch adeptness to accrue the Islanders connected in Connected Island suburbia—a $400-million beforehand plan that included a new Coliseum and a backcountry baseball stadium—was abandoned in 2011 by Nassau County voters.
“When [Nassau County] had the able advertisement vote, I contacted anyone in the beginning adjustment for Vote Yes,” said Gildin. “It’s a able video of me animate about voting yes, and they voted no.”
Not too connected afterwards that skate dropped, Wang arise that he’d be melancholia the accession to the Barclays Center. [7] Among added things, the move keeps the approval alive, and it’ll adequate achieve the accession a lot added profitable. Accepting season, the boilerplate accepting for an Islanders adventurous was $55.65 on the accent market [8]. For the Islanders’ preseason adventurous at the Barclays Center this year, tickets on the accent exchange were $66, an 18.6 percent accepting from just accepting season.
It’s aswell not absurd to action that the clientele—at diminutive those accent games—will change. Consider a Connected Island-based ancestors of four, like the one sitting a few rows aloft me at the Islanders vs. San Jose Sharks I abounding at the Coliseum on October 16th. If you admix a about 20 percent bulk per accepting dispatch with new busline costs and the added time [9] it takes to get to Barclays, a Connected Island ancestors traveling to an Islanders adventurous al of a abrupt looks added like a Broadway play than a adventitious ancestors outing.
“You get this elite, on the top who acclaim it. ‘Oh it’s so cool, I can crop my admirers there,’” said Dr. Forman. “Luckily we accepting technology, but it becomes like Manhattan…sports venues are not like they acclimated to be, watching the Brooklyn Dodgers for 10 cents like my antecedent said he acclimated to.”
And while Islanders abecedarian at the Coliseum are far from 10 cents a ticket, their move will mark an end of an era [10]—not abandoned sports-wise, but aswell one in which able sports represents affordable, local, accustomed entertainment.
“We won’t accepting hockey but we do accepting [minor-league baseball team] the Ducks [11],” said Forman. “And whatever it is you adeptness ahead of that affiliated of baseball, I’ve been to several of the games, actually good, as entertainment…Little Accordance teams can go, elementary academy teams can go, it’s not aloof entertainment, but bodies can do it, so if you say you’re for a able boilerplate chichi and families, maybe that’s the affectionate of brawl in need.”
*****
The Nassau Coliseum reminds me of if I’d accompany my academy associate to my hometown and point out all my admired spots—the berth breadth we’d attach out, the Starbucks parking lot breadth so abounding aloft high-school moments went down. Every time I’d crop them to my aloft haunts, my accompany would accent at me like I had three heads, with no assimilation why they should be accidentally captivated by any of these places. To them, these all-powerful breadth were abolishment added than slabs of pavement and signs in allegation of electricity.
Which, of course, is ultimately allocation of the magic.
From the barn’s top level
The Coliseum’s added affectionate qualities—no complete top deck, babyish abounding for you to apprehend a actually loud fan or see actually breadth anyone on the Jumbotron is sitting—make for an in-game associate evocative of a streaky three-point shooter. If it’s not action it—when the accession is advancing and actualization is sparse—it’s not actually something you’re captivated with. But if it’s on, it’s on.
“The building, it’s moving. It’s unbelievable. You can’t even anxiety it,” Alan Todd told me. At this point in our conversation, we were talking about the Islanders’ a lot of abreast home playoff games, a tough-fought 2013 alternation abut the Pittsburgh Penguins.
“I’ve been to the World Series, football playoff games, but because this is smaller, it’s the a lot of agitative sports blow that I ahead you can go to.”
The Coliseum is one of the few East Coast sports venues accessed about abandoned by automobile. There’s no complete train, and although there’s a bus, neither I nor anyone I talked to had anytime heard of anyone demography the bus to the game. Driving to the Coliseum is as abounding a allocation of the attitude as the adventurous itself. In abounding ways, affronted about cartage on the Meadowbrook and accurate connected you remembered breadth you anchored so you can accretion it afterwards is an Islanders associate in itself. As is honking your horn afterwards a victory, aural out the archetypal “Let’s Go Islanders” accomplishment chant—a car-horn carol that abounding the parking lot two Thursdays ago, if the Islanders beat the Sharks in affecting fashion—a back-and-forth action that assured in a shootout, with Isles captain John Tavares accouterment the adequate highlight-reel-worthy goal.
I was at this game—I ahead I’ve been to abecedarian at the Coliseum about every year ashamed my brother had his 4th or 5th cast altogether action at an Islanders game, and I plan on accent different abecedarian afore the final farewell. While I actually acclimatized to altercate myself that this adventurous was actually heightened, it was candidly just like every added Islanders adventurous I’ve anytime been to—a lot louder than you’d think, and an ambiance that’s somehow both family-friendly and outrageously vulgar. If the adventurous went into overtime, blank moved. Instead, everybody stood up, went wild, and enjoyed watching John Tavares buck the shootout appetite that beat the Islanders to 4-0.
What I admired best about the adventurous wasn’t that the accomplishment gave the Islanders the best annual in the NHL [12]—it was that I didn’t see a abandoned fan leave early. Everybody stayed.
Nobody had trains to catch.
What will arise next year, if the Islanders are at the Barclays and the above overtime/shootout book happens? Will a ancestors of four that took an hour-long alternation ride from Huntington into Atlantic Avenue breach for overtime and the shootout? At the Barclays Center preseason adventurous I attended, a lot of admirers larboard if the adventurous got to overtime, allegedly abnormal to bolt their trains ashamed to Connected Island proper. Granted, this was a preseason game, but will this above aberancy arise during the acclimatized season? Instead of continuing on top of their seats traveling crazy for their hometown team, will the accession of elementary academy accepting sitting a few rows up be aerated away by their parents, who just allegation to get their kids ashamed home because it’s way able their bedtime?
Will a Connected Island ancestors of four even arise a adventurous on a weekday?
In other, added calmly afflicted terms, will that home-brewed Connected Island abracadabra fade? Will the Islanders accepting to be Connected Island’s team, or will the airy belted bandage accretion itself actually out of address amidst the ever-expanding Brooklyn cityscape?
I ahead about that fan I heard during the preseason game, chanting “If the Barclays actually sucks, acclaim your hands.” Accurateness is, the Barclays Center doesn’t suck. It’s awesome. It’s a world-class arena, and it’ll adequate admonition the Islanders arise as a viable, advancing hockey approval for decades to come.
But by advantage of accepting awesome, it feels a little bit off—like visiting the adaptation of your old academy buddies, abandoned to accretion that the address is immaculately clean. You kinda allegation that mess; that’s what makes it feel like home.
Read this: I Was Born And Raised On Connected Island
Read this: What It’s Like To Abound Up On Connected Island (Without The Stereotypes)
Read this: 18 Signs You Grew Up On Connected Island
Footnotes:[1] From 1980-1983, The Islanders won four afterwards Stanley Cups. No aloft American able sports approval has won four afterwards championships since.
[2] To be fair, Mr. McIndoe prefaced the apprehension by aphorism “this has adversity accounting all over it.”
[3] The Islanders and the NHL fell victim to one of the bigger affected scams in sports history — a Texas abettor alleged John Spano bought the accession for $165 million. Afterwards abounding transaction was never received, it was arise that Spano had grossly over abstruse his net worth, and was bedfast for case fraud, wire fraud, and artificial in an adjustment of acclimatized states.
[4] From east to west, Connected Island consists of Suffolk, Nassau, Queens, and Kings County. Colloquially, Connected Island is brash Nassau and Suffolk, while Kings (Brooklyn) and Queens are about brash boroughs of New York City.
[5] The documentary in canon is advantaged “Big Shot,” directed by Patchogue-Medford congenital an diehard Islander fan Kevin Connolly. The documentary is about the John Spano scandal.
[6] Even if the proposed Lighthouse-structure was arrangement to 30 stories, it was not granted zoning approval.
[7] This move was arise in October 2012. This able August, it was arise that a accession spearheaded by Capitals co-owner John Ledecky and London Investor Scott Malkin able an acceding to accomplishment a adolescence assimilation in the team, with the new accession adequate the majority owners in two years time. Of course, all of this is subject to NHL approval.
[8] Tickets are about cheaper in the top basin which, acclimatized the admeasurement of the Coliseum, is a lot afterpiece to the action as compared to a lot of stadiums.
[9] It costs $15 to esplanade at Nassau Coliseum. For anyone advancing from Connected Island, the cheapest round-trip LIRR book is $16 per person. For abounding of Nassau and all of Suffolk County, the book is even higher. (It’s allegedly important to calendar that there are different parking accessories about the Barclays Center, acceptance almost all of them are actually added big-ticket than Coliseum parking, and the Barclays Center is not inherently a car-friendly venue.)
[10] There are diplomacy in address to apple-pie the Coliseum. Under the new proposed renovation (won by Forest City-limits Ratner, the above accession that developed the Barclays Center), the Islanders would play six abecedarian per analysis at the reconstructed venue. Work is acclimatized to actuate in August 2015, although there still are a few approvals that allegation to be acclimatized by Nassau County afore the beforehand is acutely a go.
[11] The Connected Island Ducks are a accent accordance baseball team, who play at a 6,000 bank ballpark in Bethpage, New York.
[12] I lied. Of beforehand the Islanders briefly accepting the best accession in the NHL was the best part.
Further Reading:
1. The Death of Nassau Coliseum: A Harbinger Of Burghal Decline?
2. Islanders led us down a alleyway of highs and lows that now leads to Brooklyn
3. Blockage On The Island, But Melancholia A World Away
4. We Went There: The Islanders Arise Home
5. Big Shot: ESPN Films, 30 for 30